As previously mentioned, I made a “game day decision” last Saturday night to see Bernard Haitink conduct the New York Philharmonic at Avery Fisher Hall. Note that I listed Mr. Haitink’s name first, then the orchestra, then the hall: chalk up the opportunity to see the legendary Dutch conductor in person for the first time as being the primary draw for me. He could have been conducting John Cage’s 4’33” and I probably still would have paid money for it; lucky for me, the not-quite-warhorse “Pastoral” Symphony of Beethoven was on the bill, paired with Strauss’s Don Quixote. Overall, it may not have been the most exciting or groundbreaking concert, but it was enjoyable nonetheless.
Mr. Haitink’s take on the Beethoven 6th was, in most ways, middle-of-the-road: dynamics were never extreme, tempos never dragged or felt rushed. Nothing was out of place. It was a tidy performance. And yet, it was more than that. He paid attention to details, brought out colors and instrumental phrases that I hadn’t noticed previously. It was exactly the kind of performance I was expecting and hoping for from this conductor. I couldn’t help but wonder how much more enlightening it would have been in a better hall than Avery Fisher. (There, I said it.)
Avery Fisher Hall (AFH) has never been one of my favorite orchestral venues, though I never thought that it is quite as awful as some might make it out to be. For all my previous visits to see the NY Phil at AFH, I had always been in one of the various Tiers and near the back of the hall since those afforded better views of the orchestra and the sound quality was allegedly “best” there. This time around, I made a point of getting seats in the orchestra section just to see how different it sounded. I have friends that make a point of sitting in the orchestra section at NY Phil concerts, and many online comments seem to favor the floor seats. As it turned out, my orchestra seat was pretty much dead center of the hall, both front-to-back and side-to-side; they were definitely very different, but not better, than seats in the Tiers.
In my Row Y seat, there was certainly more immediacy to the sound that favored individual instruments over blend; however, it did not feel intimate. Balances were way off. In tutti passages, the strings — especially lower strings — would get lost in a haze of fuzziness once woodwinds and brass would kick in. Percussion sound was especially dull; the wind machine in the Strauss more seen than heard. Regardless of instrument, resonance and richness was missing, as if someone had flipped a switch and turned off the overtones in the orchestra’s sound. The fourth movement storm in the Beethoven sounded tame; how much of that was due to inadequacies of the hall vs. the conductor’s restraint, I can’t be sure, but it was a disappointment nonetheless.
At least in my previous AFH seats in any of the Tiers, the blend was even and the sound more flattering to the orchestra as a whole, similar to the sound in the Orchestra or Loge section of Dorothy Chandler Pavilion. Yes, the orchestra sounded like it was playing from behind a blanket, but at least it was a single blanket for the whole orchestra, not various ones tossed around willy-nilly on some sections but not others.
It is a shame because despite the handicap presented by the hall, the NY Phil is unquestionably a fine orchestra. This was especially clear in the Don Quixote played at the beginning of the concert. Principal Cello Carter Brey entered the stage alongside Mr. Haitink, and played the lead character in Strauss’s tone poem as magnificently as you’d expect. His technique was spot on, his tone was warm, and his interpretation full of emotional and sonic range. Principal Viola Cynthia Phelps, credited as a soloist but playing the part of Sancho Panza from her usual seat at the front of the section, sounded equally impressive when you could hear her. Principal Oboe Liang Wang’s beautiful playing and nuanced timbre cut through all sonic obstacles put before it. Most impressive were the trumpets and trombones, led by legendary principals Phil Smith and Joe Alessi. Their sound has a richness and clarity that I always find stunning, no matter how many times I’ve heard it before, and the depth of tone they elicit from their respective sections is quite impressive. This was in stark contrast to the horns, which blatted about throughout the whole evening and seemed completely out of whack; even if one were willing to overlook a minor clam here or there, blend within the section was lacking, pitches were questionable, and most of all, balance with the rest of the orchestra was all wrong, as if they could only play with amplifiers turned to eleven. Even Principal Horn Phil Myers’ respectable solo work couldn’t redeem it.
All in all, though, it was enjoyable evening. I really look forward to seeing how different the NY Phil will sound with their music director, Alan Gilbert, at the helm when they visit Walt Disney Concert Hall next spring. I also hope that Mr. Haitink can be coaxed out to the West Coast to conduct the Los Angeles Philharmonic. Not sure when the last time was that he conducted the local band, if at all, but it would be a pleasure to have him out and see what rewards his moderate, detail oriented leadership would yield.
Other random thoughts:
- The NY Phil offers a pre-concert lecture one hour before concerts, similar to the LA Phil’s “Upbeat Live.” I didn’t attend in New York because, unlike in Los Angeles where Upbeat Live is free, the lectures at AFH are $7.
- Whatever one might think of audience behavior at WDCH, the audiences in New York are no different, perhaps just a tad less quiet. All the concerts I’ve attended at AFH include chatty people sitting adjacent to me, and without fail, they absolutely have to have a conversation during the quietest portion of a piece, in full voice instead of a whisper. On Saturday night, I had the added pleasure of sitting next to a very pleasant older woman who chose to wear extra helpings of the strongest, old-fashioned perfume that has ever wafted through the air.
- There are lots of doors on the orchestra level of AFH, but most people seem to only want to use the two at the back of the hall. Considering the vast quantity of seats that are located on the orchestra level, it leads to a traffic jam comparable to getting off of a 747.
- For other opinions on these concerts, here are some from The New York Times, Seen and Heard International, Classical Source, and Dwight the Connoisseur.
New York Philharmonic; Avery Fisher Hall; November 12, 2011
Bernard Haitink, conductor
Cynthia Phelps, viola
Carter Brey, cello
Strauss: Don Quixote
Beethoven: Symphony No. 6, “Pastoral”
- Bernard Haitink: Matthias Creutziger
You certainly have my sympathies about the perfume-drenched seat mate – too bad you could not ask to have her removed as a nuisance.
I found Avery Fisher better than Davies, which is of course not saying much. The sound seemed warmer and better blended, versus the general mud of Davies. At least you will get to see the NYPO in WDCH on their tour.
You’re right about the audience flow getting in and out of the house. It is not only ugly with lousy sound, the public spaces are awkward and uncomfortable. ISTR a table set up with people selling CDs on my last visit there, but that was for the ASO, not the NYPO. It was more like junior high than a major concert hall.
The most ironic thing about perfume lady was that as annoying as her perfume was, she was SO annoyed at the talking couple in front of us and she made a good chunk of noise on her own scoffing at their undisciplined behavior. She’d look at me for approval every time she’d poo-poo them. I’d just try to ignore her and hold my breath.
Where have you sat in AFH? If/when I go back there, I’ll get seats upstairs. More importantly, where do you prefer sitting in Davies?
I’ve sat a couple of times in the orchestra, fairly far foward. Once was for Mostly Mozart, when they reconfigure things by removing seats and building out the stage into the hall, the other was for ASO. Of course, I am not counting rush seats in the 1970s that got me in the first few rows for Sir Clifford Curzon playing a Mozart piano concerto or an NYPO rug concert with Boulez conducting a really unbelievable program. (I hardly remember what it sounded like – but on paper, it looks fantastic.)
Re Davies. In the orchestra, Row M and forward and NOT too far off to the sides. I mention one concert years ago where I was far to the side and maybe in row L or M and the Fazioli piano in use was incredibly loud; a friend center forward reported it seemed fairly tame to her! Breaking the tie, Josh Kosman hated the instrument and found it loud and coarse-toned.
I also attended a program this past June where I was around row U or V and the orchestra overwhelmed Yuja Wang in one of the Bartok PCs. (The two programs right after their return from Europe on the Mahler tour? Not so good.)
OTOH, for the chamber-orchestrated Shostakovich 14? 15? (whatever Conlon conducted when he was here in October), I was in row S, far to the side, and it sounded just fine.
I HATE the loge and tier seats that are to the side looking across the hall. You can see the sound flying past you but you can’t hear it that well. I don’t much like the first tier in general.
Sound in the second tier can be very god. I hear a Haydn program from up their, with a reduced orchestra, that sounded great. OTOH, I’ve heard a couple of violin concerts from the second tier and the soloists didn’t have much impact.
The terrace seats are interesting: everything is very very immediate and easy to hear. The leg room is horrifying; it’s like the balcony in the opera house or maybe worse. I once heard a program of Robin Holloway’s Fourth concerto for Orchestra, a really fun piece for giant orchestra, complete with Kraft timapani, and the Brahms violin concerto, and both worked well. The violinist was Christian Tetzlaff, who was incredible, and audible enough from the side terrace where I was sitting. He left me thinking, well, I never have to hear THAT again. He was that good, yeah.
Pingback: Listening to “Sirens” without being tied to a mast: Salonen and the LA Phil with Ax, Hillborg, and Beethoven « All is Yar